So, You Want to Be MORE Philanthropic?

Jun 9, 2025 | Charitable Gift Planning, High Net Worth Individuals

Are you an individual considering making a more meaningful and material philanthropic impact but are unsure where to start? There is no one-size-fits-all model when it comes to philanthropic giving. A variety of factors play into what type of vehicle or approach is most suitable in any given situation. Each vehicle comes with its own set of advantages and drawbacks. When considering a charitable vehicle, carefully assessing the unique aspirations is necessary to determine the most suitable approach.

Factors such as the donor’s philanthropic goals, the amount of wealth they are willing to invest in philanthropy, the geographical range of desired impact, and the level of control and flexibility desired by the funders all contribute to choosing the optimal charitable model. Also, the regulatory environment, including tax laws and reporting requirements, could significantly affect the decision-making process.

Often individuals approach us with their mind set on which vehicle they desire after hearing experiences from friends or colleagues. Other times they read online that a certain method is the best way to go to achieve “X.” However, once we look at their specific goals and needs, sometimes a separate entity isn’t necessary or efficient. Alternatively, the answer may be that we need a separate charitable entity to achieve the goals the individual and family have for their philanthropy, both short and long term. A careful approach is needed in each situation to ensure the chosen model maximizes impact and tax efficiency, allows for the desired level of involvement by the funders, and supports the individual/family’s charitable goals over time.

Below is a summary of five of the most common charitable funding vehicles we discuss with our High-Net-Worth clients when they are looking to make a greater philanthropic impact. These options are not all-encompassing of every avenue available, but they cover the basics and can act as a great starting point in a charitable plan.

Choice of Entity Matrix

Private Foundation - NonoperatingPrivate Operating FoundationPublic CharitySupporting OrganizationDonor Advised Fund
Common ActivitiesGenerally makes grants to other entitiesConducts is own active programs. May make grants but these only benefit the POF test if they are for the POF’s active programs.Grantmaking or program services, funded through public donations or fees for serviceGrantmaking or program services, typically funded through a single source and generally subject to restrictions of the supported organizationMakes grants to other entities through advisory privileges of the fund’s advisors
Charitable Deduction Percentage for Individuals30% AGI limit for cash gifts; 20% AGI limit for noncash gifts (closely held assets limited to lower of basis or FMV; marketable securities at FMV)50%/60% AGI limitation for cash donations; 30% AGI limitation for noncash gifts (closely held stock and long-term capital gain property at FMV)50%/60% AGI limitation for cash donations; 30% AGI limitation for noncash gifts (closely held stock and long-term capital gain property at FMV)50%/60% AGI limitation for cash donations; 30% AGI limitation for noncash gifts (closely held stock and long-term capital gain property at FMV)50%/60% AGI limitation for cash donations; 30% AGI limitation for noncash gifts (closely held stock and long-term capital gain property at FMV)
Control and GovernanceCan have optimal control. May have one trustee (if a trust) or two board members (if a corporation).Can have optimal control. May have one trustee (if a trust) or two board members (if a corporation).Should have a diverse board. Family and business relationships are disclosed. Governance practices are highlighted.Varying levels of control by the SO depending on SO status. Family and business relationships are disclosed. Governance practices are highlighted.No control, just “advisory” privileges. Disclosures for family, business, and governance relate to the DAF sponsor, not the DAF itself.
Donor DisclosureDonor names disclosed to the publicDonor names disclosed to the publicNO disclosure of donor names to the publicNO disclosure of donor names to the publicNO disclosure of donor names to the public
Tax Compliance FilingForm 990-PFForm 990-PFForm 990, 990-EZ or 990-NForm 990 or 990-EZNo tax return filing (included within DAF sponsor’s Form 990)
Qualification MethodDefault status is private foundation. Annual payout required.3-out-of-4 year test or 4-year aggregate test5-year ramp up period to meet the public support testDefault status is public charityDefault status is public charity
Can it Grant to a Non-(c)(3) Entity?Yes, as long as the activity is charitable. Must exercise expenditure responsibility.Yes, as long as the activity is charitable. Must exercise expenditure responsibility.Yes, as long as the activity is charitable. No expenditure responsibility required.Yes, as long as the activity is charitable. No expenditure responsibility required.Yes, as long as the activity is charitable. DAF sponsor must exercise expenditure responsibility.
Can it Receive a Grant From a Private Foundation?Yes. Expenditure responsibility required and out-of-corpus election.Yes. Expenditure responsibility required.Yes. NO extra due diligence required.Yes. NO extra due diligence required.Yes. NO extra due diligence required.
Subject to Excise Tax?Yes, 1.39% tax on net investment incomeYes, 1.39% tax on net investment incomeNO tax on net investment incomeNO tax on net investment income (unless a Type III NFI-SO)NO tax on net investment income
Annual Payout Requirement?Yes, approximately 5% of the value of non-charitable use assetsYes, calculated through the private operating foundation test (can be as low as 3.33%)No, but must meet the 33.3% public support testNo, and no public support test (unless a Type III NFI-SO)No (DAF sponsor must meet public support test but DAF itself does not)
ProsUltimate control. Name recognition.Ultimate control. Name recognition. Same charitable contribution deduction limits as public charities. May have a lower payout requirement than nonoperating foundations.Often the optimal funding vehicle. Not subject to PF regime and prohibitions. Can wholly own a business. Can do lobbying.No payout or public support test requirement.Immediate charitable contribution deduction for donors. No annual tax return filing. Easy to open and close the fund. No payout requirement. May allow for anonymity in grantmaking.
ConsSubject to PF regime and prohibitions. Lower charitable contribution deduction than POF or PC. Other PFs may not want to grant to it.Subject to PF regime and prohibitions. Other private foundations may not want to fund the POF or understand what a POF is.May have to give up control for expanded governance. Meeting the annual public support test.Lack of control. Activities are often limited to supporting those of the supported organization.Lack of control. DAF sponsor may have restrictions on certain types of allowable grants (for-profit grantees, overseas grantees, individual grantees, etc.).

As always, contact an attorney or tax advisor before making your final decision to ensure there are no unexpected consequences for your unique circumstances. If you are ready to reassess your philanthropic plan or want to learn more, connect with our knowledgeable advisors for next steps.

© 2025 Clark Nuber Wealth Management, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

This article contains general information only, and should not be construed as personalized accounting, business, financial, investment, legal, tax, or other professional advice or services, or an offer or solicitation to purchase any security or investment advisory service. The information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, we do not guarantee its accuracy, completeness, or reliability and we are not responsible or liable for any direct, indirect, or consequential losses from its use. Any such information may be incomplete and is subject to change without notice. Past performance is not indicative of future results and investing in securities involves the risk of loss, including the risk of loss of principal. You should consult with an independent financial professional and consider your personal financial circumstances, needs, and limitations before making an investment or taking any other action based on the information contained herein.